One specific tune has been lingering in my head this week, and no, it isn't from the singer's latest album. It comes by a considerably more accomplished composer: a children's entertainer. The piece is named Big Feelings and its words go: “Big feelings are OK / I’m here to stay with your big feelings.”
The Growth of Strong Emotions On the Internet
Thanks to the trend for gentle parenting, the notion of “big feelings” has become profitable on the web, and mostly I appreciate that. Being a parent, powerful emotions are challenging to escape: you are experiencing them, the little one in your house is feeling them and, in one of the biggest shifts for us as a humanity, so are countless other children on your digital streams.
Truly, videos of babies and children sobbing is so commonplace on certain platforms that numerous parents don't even question it. I avoid TikTok and my Instagram feed is mostly focused on soup and the occult, but when a colleague mentioned that she found the phenomenon disturbing, not to mention unethical, I watched some of the videos myself.
My Observations: Kids at Their Most Exposed
What I found was video after video of children at their most exposed. Crying, yelling, screaming, and sometimes acting out. I have naturally been present to these situations in my own house, but observing another person's child going through it feels excruciatingly uncomfortable, especially when that child is without reassurance by their own parent. Least forgivable is a category of video in which caregivers put their children to nasal suction while their infant or young child sobs and yells directly to camera. It is important to mention that many of the videos are not as extreme, and yet there is still something disturbing about them all.
When Strong Emotions Do Not Become Distressing
Certainly, “big feelings” aren't always wholly upsetting. When your child is sitting on the pavement distraught at the understanding that cake isn't infinite it can be difficult to keep a straight face. A lot of us have been regaled with accounts of notably iconic outbursts of our own. Mine involved screaming “GIVE ME ALL YOUR MONEY!” in the entrance of the Institute of Contemporary Arts in downtown. Lightheartedly joking your child about a time they had a outburst, or sharing a laugh with your significant other once they have retired for the night, is understandable. Capturing a child in a time of distress and posting it to the internet for all to see lacking approval is a different matter completely.
Concerning Practices and Embarrassment
Then you have the trends that are just unpleasant, such as a trend that featured startling babies into silence by flinging a processed food at their foreheads, or breaking an egg on them. That kind of content seems geared towards embarrassing children. In a piece for the a newspaper, a journalist wrote: “The eeriest part of these videos [is that] the parents are hardly connecting to their kids. Instead they are relating to a digital version of their children that they are disseminating online. And they are reveling in their authority over that image.”
The Defense of Learning Moments
There are video producers who would despise this kind of content. They claim that they are capturing their children at their most vulnerable not to ridicule them, but because they are trying to create educational instances – “just look at how peacefully and wonderfully I was able to resolve this child’s outburst using these strategies”. Some even aim to avoid certain criticism. “This video is posted to teach and increase understanding – not for endorsement or views”, a particular clip, posted by an profile run by a child doctor, apparently says. The statement that follows is one of the most self-congratulatory foolishness I have seen on the web. “If you aren't living the life, refrain from criticizing the moment.”
An Inquiry of Responsibility
What if you avoid posting the moment? I can't help but ask. Because I certainly critique these people. The impression I get, when I observe a video of a little one in anguish, whether their parent is demonstrating reassurance or not, is a failure of responsibility – the obligation to be attentive for your child. And I wonder what message it communicates, where when your child demonstrates a “big feeling”, you reach for your device. What does that say to your baby about their wholly natural emotions? “Sharing real moments is part of the learning”, reportedly.
Thoughts on Child Development
While my partner and I start touring schools for our youngster, it’s challenging not to consider how methods to child development have evolved since we were small. There is an enhanced awareness of the fact that “big feelings” are expected for little ones. These days a lot of adults try to accept those emotions and offer children a secure environment in which to share their feelings. However in spite of what the modern parenting experts claim, I do not think you can genuinely offer a safe space for your child if you are recording their instances of weakness and violating their privacy and dignity in the act. Truthfully, I do not believe these people have a great deal to instruct any of us about upbringing.
A Closing Question
A few people who will find that extreme, who would object to the fact that in particular aspects I’d rather put a dairy product on my boy’s forehead for a giggle than exploit his distress as a educational instance for clicks. But to them I would respond this: if “each conduct is message”, what, specifically, are these adults attempting to communicate?